2017-09-14 - The idea that right or not usefulness is requiredTruth Theory - Charles Sanders Perth, William James are well known

  • Perth created it and James popularized it.

  • There is a subtle disconnect between these two ideas.

  • Nishio’s Position

    • I don’t care one way or the other if “what’s useful is right” or not, because arguing about definitions of rightness isn’t useful.
    • The reason why we use the binary variable “right/wrong” in the first place is because of the need to conserve thought due to the low computational power of the human hardware twin-shema model.
    • The “useful-is-right attitude” is especially useful when discussing the correctness of decisions.
  • final

2023-12-20 merged from pragmatism 2017-08-13

  • pragmatism

  • Truth is useful for life.

  • There is no “eternal, universal truth in itself.”

    • parse Peirce
    • 1878 How to make our ideas clear?
    • Ideas are not copies of the external world.
    • Every conception has a practical meaning.
    • To “be” is to “serve the purpose of.”
    • Ideas are plans of action Dewey
    • When the city acts on that conception, will the plan be realized and the purpose achieved?
    • The meaning of the ideas we have lies in the significance they have for the action.
  • 1898 James., which became widely known because of his lectures.

  • Oswalt.

  • PoincarĂ©

  • mill et al. utilitarianism.

  • Bergson.

  • Introduction to Philosophy p.73


This page is auto-translated from /nishio/ăƒ—ăƒ©ă‚°ăƒžăƒ†ă‚Łă‚șム using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I’m very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.