Abstract-Related Page Search
2024-09-23
from [/villagepump/search for abstract-related pages](https://scrapbox.io/villagepump/search for abstract-related pages).
- Extract questions at various levels of abstraction continues to develop
- I created a system that, when you enter a consultation, pulls up “pages that are related in the abstract, but on a completely different topic in the concrete,” and explains how they can help you.
- At first glance, it looks like a typical RAG, but there is a sense of doing something much more interesting.
- demo_2.pdf (/nishio)
- User input was originally from [The hell of slacking off in the face of frustration.
- For example, a story about procrastination and a story about low self-esteem and the inability to actively ask questions are quite different in the concrete layer.
- However, the abstract structure of “behavior is hindered by emotional influences” is the same, so it can be pulled together. (Then the LLM relates the two stories to each other.)
- demo_3.pdf (/nishio)
- Consultation on habit formation
- demo_anno2.pdf (Mr. Anno’s policy manifesto)
- AI Maybe a demonstration of context would be easier to understand?
- The answer to the problem of “labor shortage in the construction industry,” which is not mentioned in the manifesto, is provided by diverting Anno’s policies toward other similar problems.
- 汎化された安野たかひろだ
- Okay, interesting.
- Scrapbox is helping me move back and forth between the abstract and the concrete.
- I don’t know where we were talking about.
- →[/shokai/2 hop link](https://scrapbox.io/shokai/2 hop link)
-
Can move back and forth between concrete and abstract in a mutually complementary manner
-
- I feel like I’m finding “analogies in different areas” by abstracting once and then searching.
-
- This experiment is able to jump to a different space by analogy by abstracting, analogous search, and then pulling back to the concrete.
- The LLM then gives a connected commentary looking at both the original space and the later space.
- I was curious to see what would happen if I only showed the space afterwards, so I tried it.
Propose a Next Action to resolve the bad situation of “low self-esteem and inability to actively ask questions” using this text. Techniques to dig deeper into the conversation…
Build on small successes: Start with easy questions and gradually get used to asking them. Build confidence through experience by realizing that it is okay to ask the wrong question.
- I think there’s a clue in the wording of this one.
- Indeed. In a “state of frustration and slacking off.”「サボっても問題はない」という安心感という発想は個人的には思いつかなかったが、「サボってはいけない」と「変な質問をしてはいけない」に共通の特徴はありそうだ。
- Indeed. In a “state of frustration and slacking off.”「サボっても問題はない」という安心感という発想は個人的には思いつかなかったが、「サボってはいけない」と「変な質問をしてはいけない」に共通の特徴はありそうだ。
- I think there’s a clue in the wording of this one.
- full log
- Using different concept spaces in parallel is [asym-chat (chat with misalignment)
- Derailment:/nishio/思考の結節点2019-01-21#5c452bf1aff09e0000bb1a70に Networks between concepts 、 metaphorical space というリンクが有る。関係する？
- RELATED.
- RELATED.
- Derailment:/nishio/思考の結節点2019-01-21#5c452bf1aff09e0000bb1a70に Networks between concepts 、 metaphorical space というリンクが有る。関係する？
- I don’t think it’s the same as if real people “only see the space after” because you can’t erase memories.
- but on the other hand, there are other cases where elimination from the active context might be beneficial
- [/nishio/Teach AI the KJ method#66eb9ccaaff09e00003b6e0d](https://scrapbox.io/nishio/Teach AI the KJ method#66eb9ccaaff09e00003b6e0d)
- Even for humans, the ability to “put it aside for a moment -” may be beneficial for thinking with a wide range of exploration
- but on the other hand, there are other cases where elimination from the active context might be beneficial
- It feels even more enhanced.
- I wanted to believe that coming and going was a human prerogative, but I feel again that it’s time to lose.
- Scrapbox is helping me move back and forth between the abstract and the concrete.
This page is auto-translated from /nishio/抽象的に関連するページの検索 using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I’m very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.