At what point do we need to point people to each other in an argument?

from [/villagepump/when is it necessary to point to someone in a discussion](https://scrapbox.io/villagepump/when is it necessary to point to someone in a discussion). /villagepump/二人称代名詞「あなた」に関する調査報告#627fb2a7aff09e00002f1eecを見て理解が進んだ

Q: When is it necessary to point people in a discussion? A: When pointing out that different viewpoints see things differently

• In many cases, “point of view” does not have a name and can only be expressed in the form of “whose point of view”.
• So, for example, we need to use expressions such as “From your point of view, X ≈ Y, but from my point of view, X ≠ Y, which can be compatible.
  • 
    • (from What is the intersection of meaning? )
• Looking back at past examples, when I started using “you” in discussions, it was often accompanied by references to “something tied to the individual” such as “Observation range”, “understanding”, “interpretation”, “subject”, etc. often accompanied by references to
  • Organized about point of view: B is X from A’s point of view, but A is also X from B’s point of view.

relevance

• [/villagepump/ Can we leave out the personals if we’re discussing opinion vs. opinion?](https://scrapbox.io/villagepump/ Can we leave out the personals if we’re discussing opinion vs. opinion?)
  • metacognition

---

This page is auto-translated from /nishio/どういう時に議論で人を指し示すことが必要か using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I’m very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.