from Polis Moderation
A rubric is a scoring or evaluation guideline used to clearly state the evaluation criteria.
Consistency of evaluation:.
- The rubric allows moderators to evaluate comments based on consistent criteria.
- The quality of moderation can be maintained by having multiple moderators use the same criteria for evaluation.
Clarification of expectations for participants:.
- By making the rubric available to participants, it is possible to clearly indicate what comments are desirable and what comments are excluded.
- Because participants do not receive direct feedback on whether their comments were approved or rejected by moderation, it is important to clarify expectations through the rubric.
Moderation efficiency:.
- A clear rubric would allow moderators to evaluate comments quickly and accurately.
- Judgment based on a rubric allows for efficient moderation without being influenced by the subjectivity of the moderator.
When creating a rubric in Polis, you may want to consider the following
- Establish criteria for excluding spam and irrelevant comments.
- Clarify how to handle duplicate comments.
- Decide how to handle comments containing multiple ideas.
- Establish criteria for comments that are consistent with the purpose of the conversation.
Implementing a rubric can help make Polis conversations more constructive and productive. It is important that there are clear guidelines for both participants and moderators.
This page is auto-translated from /nishio/ルーブリック using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I’m very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.