In project management, striking a balance between broad participation and agility (speed) is key to success. There is often a trade-off between the participation of many people and the rapid progress of the project, especially when urgency is high. This section discusses how these two aspects may conflict.
Advantages and disadvantages of broad participation
- Benefits
- Diverse perspectives : A wide range of participation can lead to diverse ideas and solutions, fostering creativity and innovation.
- Leveraging skill sets: Having members with different skills allows the project to take a more multifaceted approach.
- Disadvantages: -Disadvantages: -Disadvantages: -Disadvantages: -Disadvantages
- [Communication delays: The more participants, the more cumbersome communication becomes and the longer it takes to reach consensus.
- Delayed decision-making: The process of making decisions can be stymied by the many opinions exchanged.
Importance of agility - [Agility, or speed, is especially important, especially when deadline is imminent or when the market is volatile. [Fast decision making and quick action are necessary to maintain a competitive edge.
Managing Tradeoffs
- For urgent projects, encouraging broad participation can slow down the project. In particular, careful selection of participants is required in the following situations
- Urgent: When a project deadline is imminent, a quick response by a select few specialists may be optimal.
- Task specificity: For tasks requiring a specific high level of skill, a limited number of personnel with relevant expertise is appropriate.
Conclusion. In projects, it is important to strike a balance between “broad participation” and “agility,” but either should be prioritized depending on the situation. The project manager should carefully select the number and quality of participants according to the purpose and urgency of the project, with the goal of efficient and effective project management. While taking Brooks’s Law into account, project managers should be resourceful in using the right mix of resources and skills, rather than adding people to a project that is under fire without a plan.
This page is auto-translated from /nishio/幅広い参加と迅速さのトレードオフ using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I’m very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.