from AI’s Impact on Labor Market May Not Be Mitigated by UBI in Japan Is the effect of UBI limited in developed countries with high wages?
Q: UBI has limited effect in developed countries with high wages
synthetic technocracy No, I disagree. It is true that a universal basic income (UBI) may not have an immediate effect in countries with higher wages, but it would still provide a safety net for all. It would reduce economic insecurity, reduce the stress caused by job insecurity, and would not force people to take jobs they don’t want for fear of poverty. It would also give people the flexibility to take risks, like starting a new business or getting an education, which may ultimately lead to economic growth and innovation.
corporate libertarianism Yes, a universal basic income (UBI) would provide short-term relief to some, but it is not the best solution in developed countries with high wages. It may discourage the entrepreneurial spirit and risk-taking that drives innovation and progress. Competition, challenge, and ambition motivate people to strive for success; UBI may create a safety net, but it may also lead to a comfort zone that unintentionally inhibits individuals from reaching their full potential. Moreover, who will finance the UBI, which often leads to higher taxes, placing new burdens on businesses and stifling economic growth?
digital democracy The effects of a universal basic income (UBI) are neutral, as they depend largely on the country’s circumstances; a UBI can provide stability and the freedom for citizens to think innovatively and creatively. Developed countries may already have high wages, but the gap between rich and poor still exists; UBI has the potential to narrow this gap and encourage citizen participation in social decision-making. However, its implementation and effectiveness should be evaluated using the democratic processes and public data that constitute the key tenets of Audrey Tan’s philosophy. Thus, such conclusions cannot be confirmed without extensive, open-source research and comprehensive citizen participation.
This page is auto-translated from /nishio/高賃金の先進国ではUBIの効果は限定的？ using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I’m very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.