• idea and rarity value
  • Person A, who only rarely generates ideas, falsely believes that ideas have a high value.
  • Person B, who generates a large number of ideas on a daily basis, believes that ideas themselves are not worth that much
    • Resources (e.g., your time) to realize the idea are overwhelmingly inadequate
    • Ideas without resources are of little value.
    • Select from many ideas those that you value highly and devote your resources (time, etc.) to them.
  • The idea chosen by B is of higher quality than the idea chosen by A because it was selected from a large number of candidates.
  • B is better able to identify the quality of ideas than A because B has more experience in selecting from a large number of potential ideas.
  • Common Stories
    • A comes up with an idea and tells B that he thinks it has high value. For some reason, it is assumed that B will provide the resources to realize the idea.
    • B discards most of the ideas that do not involve resources.
    • A complains about his great idea being thrown away.
  • If the person proposing the idea is also of the same type as B:
    • The act of communicating an idea is about as “maybe it will help” as you can get.
    • If you have an idea, tell it anyway.
    • The other party is not expected to use the resources.
    • I’m not so much complaining about being thrown out.
    • The act of discarding ideas is something I do every day.
    • So, if you are the type of person who proposes an idea and doesn’t resource it and complains about throwing out ideas, you are type A.
  • Is this some sort of Dunning-Kruger effect?

Twitter @shokai

B should show A how he is whisking away ideas on a daily basis. Indeed!

rarerarerarerarerarerarerarerarerarerarerarerare

This page is auto-translated from /nishio/アイデアと希少価値 using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I’m very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.