Tried to visualize and organize a graph of mention relations between pages in Scrapbox (99 elements and 400 links) using Kozaneba

image

personal experience

  • It’s obvious to the point where you can move something that is isolated or put something that is only connected to one thing beside it.
  • From there, it suddenly becomes a conundrum.
    • Even I, who have many times KJ method experience with hundreds of cards, have difficulty in unraveling this 100-card hairball!
  • I’ll remove the chat page (8 pages) that is a huge hub from the link.
    • →The fact that it’s a large network of people who are connected to each other even when they are removed from the network doesn’t change the fact that it’s a large network.
  • what should i do?

consideration

  • I thought this was the opposite of the KJ method.

  • The KJ method is the act of looking at the whole picture and adding links from no links

  • These “hairballs unraveling at times” have too many links to see the whole picture.

    • Or, to be more precise, “it doesn’t make a planar graph, so humans can’t see over it.”
  • Maybe we need assistance in breaking the link?

  • Import Scrapbox projects into Kozaneba (Development)

Isn’t it necessary to cut the link? Discussion with ChatGPT about this - Discussion of ChatGPT and hairball unraveling

  • Isn’t it necessary to break the link?
  • Isn’t it a mistake to try to visualize the whole thing in the first place?
  • The proposal listed here would divide it into 9 pieces, but I don’t think it would be very useful.

2023-02-21

  • Impressions after some time
  • The original network is not adequate

This page is auto-translated from /nishio/ScrapboxプロジェクトをKozanebaにインポートする実験 using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I’m very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.