I heard that a book called dorm guide is good, so I bought it, and it is a really good book. 2 out of the 1-5 difficulty levels of the questions makes me groan and say “I see.
I wonder if the fact that the question assumes that the rest of the deck is known by the way means that all strong people can do card counting…
What I made last time to see Coin PerCard
- Dominion 2022-03-19 This only deals with the deck as a whole, and you don’t know what’s left in the deck, so you need a system to keep it separate.
It’s done.
It seems to be important to predict what will be drawn next, so I simulated 100,000 times and put them out in order of frequency. Also, we added a logging function so that you can look back on how things have changed.
- T4, play the blacksmith, 8 coins, here would be gold coins.
Blacksmith Stello I missed recording one turn during the process, the logging button should be next to the clean up. :
Copper 7 - mansion 3,10,3,0.70
Blacksmith 1 - copper coin 7 - house 3,11,3,0.64
Blacksmith 1 - copper coin 7 - silver coin 1 - mansion 3,12,3,0.75
Blacksmith 1 - copper coin 7 - silver coin 2 - mansion 3,13,3,0.85
Blacksmith 1 - copper coin 7 - silver coin 3 - gold coin 1 - mansion 3,15,3,1.07
Blacksmith 1 - 7 copper coins - 4 silver coins - 1 gold coin - mansion 3,16,3,1.13
Blacksmith 1 - copper 7 - silver 4 - gold 1 - mansion 3 - province 1,17,9,1.06
Blacksmith 1 - copper 7 - silver 4 - gold 2 - mansion 3 - province 1,18,9,1.17
Blacksmith 1 - copper 7 - silver 5 - gold 2 - mansion 3 - province 1,19,9,1.21
Blacksmith 1 - 7 copper coins - 5 silver coins - 2 gold coins - 3 mansions - 2,20,15,1.15
Blacksmith 1 - 7 copper coins - 5 silver coins - 3 gold coins - 3 mansions - 2,21,15,1.24
Blacksmith 1 - copper 7 - silver 5 - gold 4 - mansion 3 - province 2,22,15,1.32
Blacksmith 1 - copper 7 - silver 5 - gold 4 - mansion 3 - province 3,23,21,1.26
Blacksmith 1 - copper 7 - silver 5 - gold 4 - mansion 3 - duchy 1 - province 3,24,24,1.21
Blacksmith 1 - 7 copper coins - 5 silver coins - 4 gold coins - 3 mansions - 2 duchies - 3 provinces,25,27,1.16
Blacksmith 1 - copper 7 - silver 5 - gold 4 - mansion 3 - duchy 2 - province 4,26,33,1.12
Blacksmith 1 - copper 7 - silver 5 - gold 4 - house 3 - duchy 3 - province 4,27,36,1.07
Blacksmith 1 - copper 7 - silver 5 - gold 4 - house 4 - duchy 3 - province 4,28,37,1.04
Blacksmith 1 - 7 copper coins - 5 silver coins - 4 gold coins - 4 mansions - 4 duchies - 4 provinces,29,40,1.00
cutting off the research institute 9 coins, but if I couldn’t pull it off, I’d buy the lab. Oh, pull it off, 8 coins, then we’ll buy a genshu. :
Copper 7 - mansion 3,10,3,0.70
Copper 7-Silver 1-Mansion 3,11,3,0.82
1 gold loan - 7 copper coins - 1 silver coin - mansion 3,12,3,0.75
Gold loan 1 - copper 7 - silver 2 - mansion 3,13,3,0.85
1 gold loan - 1 guard - 6 copper coins - 2 silver coins - house 3,13,3,0.77
Moneylender 1 - Guard 1 - Institute 1 - Copper 6 - Silver 2 - House 3,14,3,0.71
1 moneylender - 1 guard - 1 laboratory - 4 copper coins - 3 silver coins - 3 mansions 3,13,3,0.77
Moneylender 1 - Guard 1 - Institute 2 - Copper 4 - Silver 3 - House 3,14,3,0.71
Moneylender 1 - Guard 1 - Institute 2 - Copper Coin 2 - Silver Coin 4 - House 3,13,3,0.77
Moneylender 1 - Guard 1 - Institute 3 - Copper Coin 2 - Silver Coin 4 - House 3,14,3,0.71
Moneylenders 1 - Guards 1 - Laboratories 4 - Copper 0 - Silver 4 - Houses 3,13,3,0.62
gold lenders 1 - guards 1 - laboratories 4 - copper coins 0 - silver coins 4 - houses 3 - gentry 1,14,9,0.57
gold lenders 1 - guards 1 - laboratories 4 - copper coins 0 - silver coins 4 - houses 3 - gentry 2,15,15,0.53
gold loan 0 - guards 1 - laboratories 4 - copper coins 0 - silver coins 4 - houses 2 - gentry 3,14,20,0.57
gold loans 0 - guards 1 - laboratories 5 - copper coins 0 - silver coins 4 - mansions 2 - provinces 3,15,20,0.53
gold loans 0 - guards 1 - laboratories 5 - copper coins 0 - silver coins 4 - mansions 1 - provinces 4,15,25,0.53
gold loan 0 - guards 1 - laboratories 5 - copper 0 - silver 4 - houses 1 - gentry 5,16,31,0.50
gold loan 0 - guards 1 - laboratories 5 - copper coins 0 - silver coins 4 - mansions 1 - gentry 6,17,37,0.47
gold loans 0 - guards 1 - laboratories 5 - copper coins 0 - silver coins 4 - mansions 1 - duchies 1 - provinces 6,18,40,0.44
It’s hard with the current UI to return the silver coins after seeing them under the Guard’s effect.
- You draw, play the silver coin in your hand, then discard it, separately acquire the silver coin and put it back in the discard back in the deck, and because you’re really top-decked and don’t know it, the simulation of the next draw doesn’t work and you have to draw by hand.
- Either add a button to return the card from your hand to the top of the deck.
- Or, since there are so many cards that temporarily look at deck taps, put a “put in not hand” button next to the current random draw button, and give the cards in that zone a “discard, discard, return to deck top” button.
- I really wanted to combine them into one scatter plot, but I couldn’t figure out how to do it in Google Spreadsheet, so I just laid them out roughly to scale.
- Horizontal axis is the number of cards and vertical axis is the average amount of money coin per card
- In the blacksmith stero on the left, the amount of gold increases to about 1.3 while monotonically increasing the number of cards, then declines as the winning points come in
- In the right lab pullout, it’s going up and down around 0.75 and then down.
- If you’re going to pull off a village blacksmith in a workshop, you’re going to get more pieces even faster than a blacksmith stero.
- A chapel stero would increase the amount of money at a fast pace once the number of cards is reduced, and would decrease at a faster pace if you buy victory points.
Chapel - Copper - Copper - Silver - House: 29%. Is this okay to leave the silver coins?
Chapel - silver - silver - silver - silver: 75 With only 6 chapels and silver coins in the deck, this is inevitably what happens, but I’m not sure which is correct, the gold or the gentry.
Oh, I feel like I made a mistake (maybe I bought a genus for 7 coins? ), there’s no way to check or go back and redo it, so I’ll have to start all over again from the beginning. I’ve got the logs in CSV format on the screen for easy copying and pasting into a spreadsheet, but I’m getting them in JSON, so I’d better put enough information in there and add an Undo button or something.
It’s done.
Chapel 1 - Copper 7 - House 3,11,3,0.64
Chapel 1 - copper coin 7 - silver coin 1 - mansion 3,12,3,0.75
Chapel 1 - copper coin 7 - silver coin 2 - mansion 3,13,3,0.85
Chapel 1 - 5 copper coins - 2 silver coins - house 2,10,2,0.90
Chapel 1 - 5 copper coins - 3 silver coins - house 2,11,2,1.00
Chapel 1 - 3 copper coins - 3 silver coins - house 1,8,1,1.13
Chapel 1 - 3 copper coins - 3 silver coins - 1 gold coin - house 1,9,1,1.33
Chapel 1 - copper coin 1 - silver coin 4 - gold coin 1 - mansion 1,8,1,1.50
Chapel 1 - copper coin 1 - silver coin 4 - gold coin 1 - mansion 1 - province 1,9,7,1.33
Chapel 1 - 4 silver coins - 1 gold coin - 1 mansion - Province 1,8,7,1.38
Chapel 1 - Silver 4 - Gold 2 - House 1 - Province 1,9,7,1.56
Chapel 1 - 4 silver coins - 2 gold coins - House 1 - Province 2,10,13,1.40
Chapel 1 - 4 silver coins - 3 gold coins - house 1 - provinces 2,11,13,1.55
Chapel 1 - 4 silver coins - 4 gold coins - house 1 - provinces 2,12,13,1.67
Chapel 1 - 4 silver coins - 4 gold coins - house 1 - provinces 3,13,19,1.54
Chapel 1 - 5 silver coins - 4 gold coins - Province 3,13,18,1.69
Chapel 1 - 5 silver coins - 4 gold coins - Province 4,14,24,1.57
Chapel 1 - Silver 5 - Gold 4 - Duchy 1 - Province 4,15,27,1.47
Chapel 1 - Silver 5 - Gold 4 - Duchy 2 - Province 5,17,36,1.29
Chapel 1 - Silver 5 - Gold 4 - Duchy 3 - Province 5,18,39,1.22
Chapel 1 - silver 5 - gold 4 - duchy 4 - province 5,19,42,1.16
Chapel 1 - silver 5 - gold 4 - duchy 5 - province 5,20,45,1.10
https://twitter.com/nishio/status/1507790327390048257?s=21
This page is auto-translated from [/nishio/Dominion 2022-03-26](https://scrapbox.io/nishio/Dominion 2022-03-26) using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I’m very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.