nishio: I was disappointed that my friend didnā€™t get it when I said ā€œChatGPT is smart-assā€, but Iā€™m glad to know that at least Dr. Rekimoto will get it. I was relieved to know that at least Dr. Rekimoto would get the message.

from /villagepump/2023/03/15

  • I was talking to ChatGPT4 and I was thinking that it looks like somethingā€¦ deja vuā€¦ Iā€™m starting to get the feeling that there are guys like this out there.
  • With this kind of guy.
    • Heā€™s quick-witted and babbles words at high speed.
    • I know a lot of terms and scatter them as appropriate.
    • When you talk like that verbally, most people canā€™t follow you, so they feel ā€œhuh, a smart person is talking about something difficult that I donā€™t understandā€.
      • So Iā€™m sure this behavior is reinforced by the benefits of usually doing that kind of activity.
    • But if you read the recorded statements carefully and in writing, they donā€™t say much.
      • Itā€™s just a bunch of random words you came up with.
        • Well, thatā€™s how LLM works, so thatā€™s how it is, I guess.
    • The stories are connected topically, but thereā€™s no big picture as a whole.
      • I feel like Iā€™m just embellishing a poor assumption with clever vocabulary because I donā€™t know what Iā€™m talking about.

I was transcribing and summarizing the above on 2023-03-18 and a picture came to mind. image

  • 1 people have a hard time putting what they want to say into words, and even when they do their best to verbalize it, the story can be twisted.
  • Compared to that person, a person who can tell a straight story is perceived as ā€œsmart. - fluency
  • If we consider this axis as ā€œsmartā€, GPT4 would be ā€œsmartā€.
  • However, when I actually talked to GPT4, my feeling was the opposite: ā€œThis guy is an idiot acting like heā€™s smart.
  • What gave rise to this sensation?
  • Possibly related to - Ideas inspired by a single stimulus

2023/8/31


This page is auto-translated from /nishio/ChatGPTćÆé ­ć®ć„ć„ć‚¢ćƒ› using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. Iā€™m very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.