Some say, âDescartes didnât create anything, but he left thought behind,â and others say, âIn Descartesâ time, putting thoughts into a book was a major project.â What do you think?
The opinion that âDescartes did not create anything but left behind ideasâ and the opinion that âin Descartesâ time, compiling ideas into books was a major projectâ both contain some truth, but they evaluate Descartesâ accomplishments from different aspects.
When Descartes says that he âdid not create anything,â he probably means that he did not leave behind any physical inventions or concrete technical achievements. However, his ideas, especially the proposition âI think, therefore I amâ (Cogito, ergo sum), occupy a very important place in Western philosophy. This idea offered a new perspective on subjectivity, self-awareness, and the foundations of knowledge. Descartes, through his methodological skepticism and rationalism, changed the very way knowledge is sought.
On the other hand, the opinion that âin Descartesâ time, the compilation of ideas into books was a major projectâ emphasizes the social and cultural context of his achievements. 17th century Europe was a time of the spread of knowledge with the development of printing technology. Books became the primary means of disseminating new ideas and scientific knowledge. Descartesâ writings were also written against this background and widely read. His writings were influential not only because of the innovative nature of his ideas, but also because of the media that existed to disseminate them.
To appreciate Descartesâ work, it is important to understand the philosophical depth of his ideas as well as the role of books as a means of communicating them. He may not have left behind any physical âobjects,â but his ideas continue to have a profound impact on later generations in the form of books. This is because they were an effective means of disseminating ideas in the cultural and technological context in which Descartes lived.
Comments
.
The fact that âbooksâ were âan effective means of disseminating ideas in the cultural and technological context of Descartesâ timeâ doesnât mean that âbooksâ are âan effective means of disseminating ideasâ in the cultural and technological context of today.
This page is auto-translated from /nishio/ææłăćșăăææź” using DeepL. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. Iâm very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.